Batman’s new Joker replacement breaks a trend that has been set in all of the Dark Knight’s live-action films

Batman: The Masked Crusader employs its version of Harley Quinn to replace the Joker for at least the first season of the DC show, and through its story manages to break a long-standing trend towards live-action movies in a fascinating way. The animated Batman show will reimagine a lot about Gotham and its characters, with that focus on mixing it up with the general rogues gallery, which perhaps explains why the Joker is currently missing from both preview photos and the Batman: The Masked Crusader Trailer.

With that in mind, Quinn appears to be the main clown-based criminal, at least in the first chapter of the series. Which makes it all the more interesting that the changes to Harley’s story in the upcoming DC release take a path that is both completely unusual and entirely fitting to the Batman mythos.

Related

All 33 Batman animated films ranked from worst to best

From original stories like The Mask of the Phantom to adaptations like The Dark Knight Returns, here you’ll find all the Batman animated films, ranked from worst to best.

Batman: Caped Crusader breaks a major Dark Knight trend by giving Bruce Wayne a psychiatrist

Batman: The Masked Crusader enters territory that the live-action Batman films have never fully explored by giving Bruce Wayne a real psychiatrist in the form of Dr. Harleen Quinzel. In comparison, the films have only ever explored this storyline via psychologist Chase Meridian in Batman foreverand even then, it seemed clear that Kilmer’s Wayne was visiting Meridian for romantic reasons, not for psychiatric treatment.

Giving Bruce Wayne a psychiatrist or psychologist makes a lot of sense for the character, making this decision a particularly interesting part of the upcoming show. This is even more true because, much like Bruce’s double life as a billionaire and Batman, Harleen works as a psychiatrist by day and Harley Quinn by night, meaning her role as Bruce’s psychiatrist should provide a real opportunity to explore the parallels between these two versions of iconic DC characters.

Why Caped Crusader breaks the long-term Batman trend

Although one would naturally assume that Bruce’s childhood trauma and subsequent desire for justice might benefit from psychiatric treatment, it seems that Batman: The Masked Crusader won’t tackle this in the way audiences might expect. In fact, it seems that while Batman’s focus on his life as a vigilante is damaging to his ability to exist as a human being, his strict focus has its roots only in the tragedy of his parents’ murder.

When Bruce Timm spoke about the series in a preview of the upcoming series, he mentioned to Entertainment Weekly that this Batman “a really strange person… He’s not obsessed with the murder of his parents, but he’s changed so much by it that he’s still not used to being human. He’s literally Batman; he is on the inside. When he’s Bruce Wayne, he’s not just without a mask; he’s wearing a human suit. He’s trying to pretend to be something he’s not.”

Based on this, it seems more likely that these psychiatrist sessions are a way of demonstrating this lack of adjustment to the audience, rather than focusing exclusively on the more conventional lines of Batman’s focus on the crime that destroyed his own life and the grief of that event. A Batman whose Bruce Wayne persona is entirely a “Person Suit“Because of his total dedication to his superhero life, he should also be a character whose interactions with a psychiatrist in his civilian form are really fascinating.

The psychiatrist story of Batman: Caped Crusader fits perfectly into the reinterpreted DC world

Batman: The Masked Crusader is set to ” .an incredibly complex psychological story about someone who needs to be redeemed in some way” based on series creator JJ Abrams’ own words at DC FanDome 2021. So it makes sense to have ways of clearly conveying this aspect of the story to audiences. Giving Bruce Wayne a psychiatrist – especially one who has a secret alter ego of his own – is a great way to directly address the deeper themes and psychological aspects of Crusader with cape‘s narrative, with the suspense maintained due to Harley’s double life.

Since the Joker is apparently missing in Batman: The Masked Crusader Season 1 due to its absence in promotional materials, it seems particularly easy to have Harley Quinn instead take on the role of Batman’s direct nemesis for the foreseeable future, making her civilian job even more perfect due to his proximity to the DC hero. All of this can serve to enable perfect Batman: The Masked Crusader as a more atmospheric, more adult idea of Batman: The Animated Series‘ world and allow the show to delve deeper into topics not covered in the original.

Batman: The Masked Crusader (2024)

Transformed by tragedy, wealthy socialite Bruce Wayne takes on the role of Batman to fight rampant corruption and crime in Gotham City. His vigilantism attracts both allies within the GCPD and City Hall and deadly adversaries, leading to unforeseen consequences. The series delves into Batman’s noir roots and explores the psychological depths of Gotham’s residents.