Love Island USA fans catch Aaron shaking Kaylor’s hand with Daniela

Casa Amor is the ultimate Love Island Relationship test, and it seems to be difficult for USA star Aaron Evans.

Aaron, 26, is married to Kaylor Martin in Season 6 of the reality TV series Peacock since Day 1. Earlier this week, Aaron and the rest of the guys decided to head from the villa to Casa Amor to meet a bunch of new bombshells.

Getting to know new islanders Daniela Ortiz-RiveraAaron locked his pinkies with her during a private conversation. They then kissed each other’s fingers. Social media fans soon remembered Aaron making a similar gesture with 22-year-old Kaylor in the OG mansion.

“This is crazy,” one X user commented. “So, I’m sick.”

Related: “Love Island USA” status check: Which couples are still together?

They got a text message – and found love in the Love Island USA villa. The popular British dating show came across the pond in 2019 and followed a group of American sex bombs looking for the one in a luxurious tropical villa. In season 1, eventual winners Elizabeth Weber and Zac Mirabelli had a connection (…)

Another added: “Oh my god no way she’s going to cry. Oh Kaylor I’m so sorry.”

Other fans called Aaron a “player” for apparently reviving his flirting behavior, and hoped that word would get around to Kaylor in the main villa so she could hook up with a new guy in the next few days.

“THIS NEEDS TO BE ON THE POSTCARD! @loveislandusa: Same secret handshake?????” a fourth fan wrote about X, referring to the show’s storyline in which the ladies are sent photos of how their partners are behaving while they are away.

During their time in Casa, Aaron bonded with 22-year-old Daniela as they speak Spanish and are vegan. He also called the bombshell a “hot commodity” and stressed, “I already feel like I love you so much,” before they shared a passionate kiss.

At the end of the Casa experiment, each OG islander can choose to stay with their partner or team up with someone new. Aaron is unhappy with his decision.

“It’s really difficult (because) Daniela is really, really nice,” he said in a confessional. “She’s really, really sweet. She’s super, like, kindhearted. So a lot of boxes (checked off).”

Kaylor, for her part, doesn’t feel so torn, even though she kisses the sex bomb Ignacio Ferrari in a game of spin the bottle.

“It’s hard not to think about the other person when you’re here and they’re gone,” Kaylor, who was shown crying several times because she missed Aaron, said after the game. “I feel like Aaron and I have such a strong connection, so that’s definitely going to be tested.”

New episodes of Love Island USA airs six days a week at 6pm PT / 9pm ET on Peacock.