close
close

Books in which the villain is actually the hero

Books in which the villain is actually the hero

“Children of Fear and Anarchy” by Tomi Adeyemi

With beautifully crafted edges, dazzling metallic foil designs on the cover and sleeve, and an exclusive endpaper card revealing new, unexplored territories, Tomi Adeyemi’s bestselling Legacy of Orïsha series comes to a world-shattering conclusion.

Manipulating morality is a fine thing. Perhaps that’s why books in which the villain is actually the hero are just the thing.

This reversal of the hero versus villain dynamic plays with our ideas about the public’s perception of good and evil. Often, systems of power are not inherently just, but they establish a set of rules and laws that govern good and evil on a grand scale.

It’s much easier to think of rich, powerful people as good because, if you follow the just world fallacy, they worked hard to deserve it. On the other hand, by the same principle, if something goes wrong, it’s their fault. Just like many psychological principles, it’s just one of those things that often feels intuitively right, but isn’t.

However, the underlying idea is what makes the “villain is actually the hero” situation compelling. It disproves the fallacy of a just world and reveals a darker truth about broken legal systems. “The Villain is Actually the Hero” also aims to correct historical anti-Semitic, racist, ableist, and homophobic villain stereotypes.

Sometimes goodness and heroism are misconstrued in the stories and social structures we are taught growing up. The only way to correct this is to go through the difficult process of finding out the truth that the hero was the bad guy all along. “The villain is actually the hero” is always satisfying because even if no one else notices that the hero is the problem, the villain is there to thwart them.

Below you’ll find a mix of adult fantasy, romance, and young adult fantasy with a must-read graphic novel. “The villain is actually the hero” can pop up pretty much anywhere. These are just a few of my favorites.

Shockingly heroic fantasy for adults

Hench by Natalie Zina Walschots book coverHench by Natalie Zina Walschots book cover

Hench by Natalie Zina Walschots

Anna found it tough being stuck in the villain gig economy doing office work, but when she gets pulled into a villainous revelation, the hero who resolves the event breaks her down too. Injured, with no medical benefits or insurance, Anna has no choice but to slowly recover and create a spreadsheet listing the damage the heroes have done to the city. Her viral campaign lands her a full-time job with the city’s worst villain, but who wouldn’t root for the villain with such heroism?

Vicious by VE Schwab book coverVicious by VE Schwab book cover

Evil by VE Schwab

It’s impossible to write a “villain is actually the hero” book list without mentioning asexual darling Victor. In college, Victor and Eli were simply brilliant roommates researching how to develop extraordinary abilities through near-death experiences. Ten years later, Eli is a celebrated hero, celebrated for killing anyone with extraordinary abilities he can find, and Victor is a recently escaped villain whose only goal is to take Eli down. Across two timelines, their complicated relationship with their sense of justice reveals that the real villain was the hero all along.

Book cover “A Feather So Black” by Lyra SeleneBook cover “A Feather So Black” by Lyra Selene

A feather so black by Lyra Selene

In the human kingdom, shapeshifters like Fia are rare. When the war between the fae and humans ended, the fae retreated to Tír na nÓg and stole the High Queen’s daughter, leaving Fia in her place. Raised as the Queen’s spy, her affinity for plants became a perfect poison against the evil fae. So when the Queen tells her she must go through the Gate to get her stolen daughter back, Fia says yes, even though she is accompanied by her first boyfriend, her lover, and the man who broke her heart. When they go to Tír na nÓg for one night once a month to get the princess back, Fia discovers that the evil fae may not be as evil as she was led to believe.

Romantasy, where the villain is actually the hero

Book cover “That Time I Got Drunk and Saved a Demon” by Kimberly LemmingBook cover “That Time I Got Drunk and Saved a Demon” by Kimberly Lemming

Back when I was drunk and saved a demon by Kimberly Lemmings

Everyone is excited as the goddess chooses her chosen ones for a mission. Everyone except Cinnamon, who would rather stay home. When she drunkenly encounters a dragon shifter demon on the way home and protects herself with cinnamon, Cinn’s worldview changes. It turns out that the goddess is a witch who enslaves demons with mind control, and the awakened demon Fallon wants Cinn’s help to defeat her. Reluctantly, Cinn embarks on a mission to save all the demons, with Fallon, a shapeshifter who wants to woo her before her journey is over.

Book cover “King of Battle and Blood” by Scarlett St. ClairBook cover “King of Battle and Blood” by Scarlett St. Clair

King of Battle and Blood by Scarlett St. Clair

All her life, Isolde has been told that even among the evil vampires, there is no one as malicious as Adrian, the Vampire King. At the end of a difficult conflict, the only way to save her people is to marry Adrian. Isolde plans to kill him while she can, but when her wedding night assassination attempt fails, she begins to uncover the truth behind the Vampire Court. When the evil of her home kingdom and the benevolence of the Vampire Court are revealed, Isolde must reorient her goals to stay on the right side.

The hero is the villain in YA SFF

Book cover “Legendborn” by Tracy DeonnBook cover “Legendborn” by Tracy Deonn

Born into legend by Tracy Deon

Bree thought the most dangerous thing about partying in the woods was the risk of being kicked out of the UNC–Chapel Hill boarding school program. When demons appear, the students either run away or chase the creatures. She discovers that there is a secret group of supposed heroes, the descendants of King Arthur’s knights, whose job it is to defeat the unseen threat to the world that may have something to do with her mother’s death. Bree is willing to risk her life to find out who the real villains are.

Book cover “Iron Widow” by Xiran Jay ZhaoBook cover “Iron Widow” by Xiran Jay Zhao

Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao

Zetian lives in a world where teenagers, linked to girls via psychic links to pilot robot suits, fight aliens. She desperately wants to be chosen for the program – not to save the world, but to avenge her sister’s death. When she is finally chosen, she unexpectedly overpowers and kills the pilot responsible for her sister’s death. She’s gotten her revenge, but now she must face what comes next. Zetian is too powerful to imprison, but to get her under control, they pair her with the strongest male pilot, and she’ll have to work that much harder to survive their partnership.

A not so evil graphic novel

Book cover “Nimona” by ND StevensonBook cover “Nimona” by ND Stevenson

Nimona by ND Stevenson

Young shapeshifter Nimona wants nothing more than to be the henchman of supervillain Lord Blackheart. They’re determined to expose that lawmen like Sir Goldenloin aren’t nearly as good as they want everyone to believe. But will Nimona’s impulsiveness and mysterious past get in the way of their revenge? This is a deeply heartfelt, award-winning graphic novel that questions everything from government to the gender binary in elegant and hilarious ways.

There will never be enough books where the villain is actually the hero. Each time, authors explore new ideas of villainy and goodness by exposing cultural stereotypes and historical injustices. If you’re interested in other highly specific book recommendations to get you thinking, may I recommend the best sentient houses in literature, young adult books for fans of Greek mythology, and historical fantasy books that are must-reads.