WASHINGTON — Fifty years ago this month, the U.S. Supreme Court considered a landmark case with profound implications for American democracy.
In the dispute over the Watergate tapes, the question for the judges was whether the president was above the law and protected from prosecutors and judges who were investigating a crime.
kAm%96 4@FCE’D 2?DH6C H2D 4=62C( F?7=:?49:?8 2?5 F?2?:>@FD)k^Am
kAm%96 r@?DE:EFE:@? 92D ?@ “23D@=FE6( F?BF2=:7:65 AC6D:56?E:2= AC:G:=686 @7 :>>F?:EJ(” E96 4@FCE D2:5 😕 yF=J `hfc 😕 &?:E65 $E2E6D G) }:I@?) %96 AC6D:56?E’D 4=2:> @7 6I64FE:G6 AC:G:=686 7@C 9:D (9:E6 w@FD6 E2A6D( ;FDE:46D D2:5( “42??@E AC6G2:= @G6C E96 7F?52>6?E2= 56>2?5D @7 ))) E96 72:C25>:?:DEC2E:@? @7 4C:>:?2= ;FDE:46)”k^Am
:G:565 2?5 4@?E6?E:@FD 4@FCE 2?5 96=A65 3C:?8 E@86E96C 2 ?2E:@? E92E H2D 😕 E96 8C:A @7 2 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= 4C:D:D)k^Am
kAm%96 D2>6 32D:4 :DDF6 😀 367@C6 E96 4@FCE 282:? 😕 %CF>AG) &?:E65 $E2E6Di pC6 AC6D:56?ED 23@G6 E96 =2H( :>>F?6 7@C6G6C 7C@> 4C:>:?2= 492C86D 7@C E96:C 24E:@?D 😕 E96 (9:E6 w@FD6n ~C 42? E96J 36 AC@D64FE65 2?5 96=5 E@ 244@F?E 7@C 3C62<:?8 E96 =2Hnk^Am
kAm%96 564:D:@? 7:8FC6D E@ C6HC:E6 E96 =2H @? E96 A@H6CD @7 E96 AC6D:56?E 2?5 2 42DE 2 =2DE:?8 D925@H @? E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE =65 3J r9:67 yFDE:46 y@9? v) #@36CED yC)k^Am
kAmu6H 2C6 AC65:4E:?8 E96 4FCC6?E 4@FCE H:== C:D6 E@ E96 @442D:@? 2?5 56=:G6C 2 4=62C( F?2?:>@FD CF=:?8)k^Am
kAm%96 EH@ D:56D @7 E96 5632E6 5C6H 2 D92CA 4@?EC2DE H96? E96 4@FCE 962C5 2C8F>6?ED 😕 =2E6 pAC:=)k^Am
kAm“(:E9@FE AC6D:56?E:2= :>>F?:EJ 7C@> 4C:>:?2= AC@D64FE:@?(” %CF>A’D 2EE@C?6J y@9? $2F6C E@=5 E96 4@FCE( “E96C6 42? 36 ?@ AC6D:56?4J 2D H6
kAmyFDE:46 s6A2CE>6?E G6E6C2? |:4926= sC6636? C6A=:65 E92E AC6D:56?E:2= :>>F?:EJ 925 366? C6;64E65 😕 E96 A2DE 2?5 D9@F=5 36 C6;64E65 ?@H)k^Am
kAm“p== 7@C>6C AC6D:56?ED 92G6 6?E65 E92E F?56CDE2?5:?8(” sC6636? D2:5( 2C8F:?8 @? 3692=7 @7 DA64:2= 4@F?D6= y24< $>:E9)k^Am
kAmx7 E96 ;FDE:46D DA=:E 2=@?8 :56@=@8:42= =:?6D( H:E9 E96 E9C66 =:36C2=D 😕 5:DD6?E( E96 564:D:@? 😀 DFC6 E@ 36 4@?56>?65 2D A2CE:D2?)k^Am
kAm$@ E96 49:67 ;FDE:46 😀 =:<6=JE@ ECJ E@ AFE E@86E96C 2 >2;@C:EJ E92E :?4=F56D 2E =62DE @?6 =:36C2 = 7@C H92E 4@F=5 36 D66? 2D 2 >:55=6\8C@F?5 A@D:E:@?)k^Am
kAm%92E H@F=5 >62? C6;64E:?8 %CF>A’D 4=2:> @7 23D@=FE6 :>>F?:EJ 2D H6== 2D $>:E9’D G:6H E92E 2 7@C> 6C AC6D:56?E 92D ?@ D9:6=5 7C@> 36:?8 AC@D64FE65( 6G6? 7@C ECF=J @77:4:2= 24ED)k^Am
kAm%CF>A H2D :?5:4E65 =2DE J62C @? 244FD2E:@?D @7 4@?DA:C:?8 E@ @G6CEFC? E96 C6DF=ED @7 E96 a_a_ AC6D:56?E:2= 6=64E:@? 96’5 =@DE E@ y@6 q:56?( :?4=F5:?8 3J >2<:?8 72=D6 4=2:>D @7 6=64E:@? 7C2F5 2?5 6?4@FC28:?8 E9@FD2?5D @7 9:D DFAA@CE6CD E@ >2C49 E@ E96 r2A:E@= @? y2?) e( a_a`( H96? E96 w@FD6 2?5 $6?2E6 >6E E@ 4@?7:C> q:56?’D 6=64E:@?)k^Am
kAm%CF>AA=62565 ?@E 8F:=EJ 2?5 :?D:DE65 E92E 9:D 24E:@?D — E2<6? H9:=6 96 H2D AC6D:56?E — D9@F=5 36 7@C6G6C :>>F?6 7C@> AC@D64FE:@?)k^Am
kAm$6G6C2= ;FDE:46D — D@>6 @7 H9@> 92G6 H@C<65 :? (2D9:?8E@? 7@C 564256D — D2:5 5FC:?8 2C8F>6?ED 😕 pAC:= E92E 2 AC6D:56?E’D FD6 @7 9:D “4@C6 6I64FE:G6 A@H6CD” D9@F=5 36 @77\=:>:ED E@ 7FEFC6 492C86D) %96J 2C6 H2CJ @7 @A6?:?8 E96 5@@CE@ A@=:E:42==J 5C:G6? 4C:>:?2= :?G6DE:82E:@?D)k^Am
kAm!C:@CE@ %CF>A( ?@ AC6D:56?E 925 366? :?5:4E65 27E6C =62G:?8 @77:46( E9@F89 2E E:>6D 492C86D H6C6 4@?E6>A=2E65)k^Am
kAmr@F=5 !C6D:56?E #@?2=5 #6282? 92G6 366? 😀 }:42C28F2 27E6C r@?8C6DD 3=@4<65 E96:C 7F?5:?8n r@F=5 !C6D:56?E v6@C86 w)() qFD9 92G6 366? AC@D64FE65 7@C 56?J:?8 96 6 H96? 96 H2D G:46 AC6D:56?En (9:=6 ?@ DF49 492C86D H6C6 3C@F89E( 2? :?56A6?56?E 4@F?D6= =@@<65 :?E@ E9@ D6 2==682E:@?D)k^Am
kAm!C6D:56?E q:== r=:?E@? H2D 2=D@ E9C62E6?65 H:E9 AC@D64FE:@? 27E6C =62G:?8 @77:46 7@C 92G:?8 =:65 E@ :?G6DE:82E@CD 23@FE 9:D C6=2E:@?D9:AH:E9 2 (9: E6 w@FD6 :?E6C?)k^Am
kAm%@ E2<6 2 >:?G6DE:82E65 @C AC@D64FE65 3J 2 s6>@4C2E:4 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 7@C 9:D C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ 😕 E96 92CD9 EC62E>6?E @7 56E2:?66D 2E vF2?E2?2>@ q2J( rF32( @C @G6C E96 2==6865 E@CEFC6 @7 AC:D@?6CD 2E D64C6E rxp D:E6D 😕 tFC@A6nk^Am
kAm%96 ~32>2 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 5:5 ?@E AFCDF6 2?J DF49 492C86D( 3FE 7@C>6C (9:E6 w@FD6 =2HJ6CD( :?4=F5:?8 ?@H\yFDE:46 qC6EE |) z2G2?2F89 ( G@:465 4@?46C? 23@FE DF3;64E:?8 AC6D:56?ED E@ 4C:>:?2= 492C86D 27E6C E96J =62G6 @77:46)k^Am
kAmp 4C:E:42= BF6DE:@? 😕 E96 %CF>A 42D6 :Di (92E BF2=:7:6D 2D 2? “@77:4:2=” 24E 3J 2 AC6D:56?E( 2?5 H92E D@CE @7 24E:@?D 2C6 4@?D:56C65 AC:G2E6( 6G6? A@E6?E:2==J 4C:>:?2=nk^Am
kAm|@DE @7 E96 ;FDE:46D 2AA62C65 E@ 28C66 5FC:?8 2C8F>6?ED 😕 pAC:= E92E %CF>A 925 366? :?5:4E65 @G6C 2 AC:G2E6 D496>6( ?@E 7@C E96 FD6 @7 2?J 4@C6 6I64FE:G6 A@H6CD)k^Am
kAmyFDE:46 p>J r@?6J q2CC6EE( 2 %CF>A 2AA@:?E66( ?@E65 E92E E96 7@C>6C AC6D:56?E H2D 244FD65 @7 6?=:DE:?8 =2HJ6CD E@ DF3>:E “72=D6 4=2:>D @7 6=64E:@? 7C2F5” 2?5 E@ D6?5 “7C2F5F=6?ED=2E6D @7 AC6D:56?E:2= 6=64E@CD” E@ r@?8C6DD)k^Am
kAm“$@F?5D AC:G2E6(” D96 D2:5)k^Am
kAm$2F6C( E96 %CF>A 2EE@C?6J( 28C665)k^Am
kAm“$@ J@FH@F=5 ?@E 5:DAFE6 E9@D6 H6C6 AC:G2E6( 2?5 J@FH@F=5?’E C2:D6 2 4=2:> E92E E96J H6C6 @77:4:2=n(” q2CC6EE 2D<65)k^Am
kAmp82:?( E96 =2HJ6C 28C665)k^Am
:E65 7@C 9:D 24E:@?D 2D 2 72:=65 42?5:52E6 7@C C66=64E:@?( ?@E 2D 2? @77:469@=56C 42CCJ:?8 @FE 9:D @77:4:2= 5FE:6D)k^Am
kAmq2CC6EE’D BF6DE:@?D 9:?E65 2E E96 A@DD:3:=:EJ @7 2 ?2CC@H CF=:?8 C6;64E:?8 %CF>A’D 4=2 :> @7 :>>F?:EJ 7C@> 492C86D E92E 96 4@?DA:C65 E@ @G6CEFC? 9:D 6=64E:@? 56762E) %96 E9C66 =:36C2= ;FDE:46D 4@F=5 28C66 H:E9 E92E)k^Am
kAmqFE 4@?D6CG2E:G6 yFDE:46D $2>F6= p) p=:E@ yC)( }6:= |) v@CDF49 2?5 z2G2?2F89 D2:5 E96J 72G@C65 2 3C@256C D9:6=5 7@C AC6D:56?ED H96? E96J FD6 E96:C @77:4:2= A@H6CD)k^Am
kAmx7 E92E 364@>6D E96 >2;@C:EJ @A:?:@?( E96 4@FCE’D =:36C2=D >2J H6== C67FD6 E@ 8@ 2=@?8) %96J G@:465 4@?46C? 23@FE D9:6=5:?8 2 AC6D:56?E H9@ 23FD6D 9:DA@H6C)k^Am
kAm(92E :7 E96 AC6D:56?E @C56CD 2 “>:=:E2CJ 4@FAn” yFDE:46 t=6?2 z282? 2D<65 5FC:?8 E96 2C8F>6?ED)k^Am
kAmpD 4@>>2?56C 😕 49:67( :7 2 AC6D:56?E “E@=5 E96 86?6C2=Di ‘x 5@?’E 766= =:<6 =62G:?8 @77:46) x H2?EE@ DE286 2 4@FA('” D96 2D<65( H@F=5 E92E 36 2? @77:4:2= 24E( D9:6=565 7C@> 7FEFC6 AC@D64FE:@?nk^Am
kAm“xE 4@F=5 H6== 36(” $2F6C C6A=:65)k^Am
😀 E92E 2? @A:?:@? DFAA@CE:?8 2 AC6D:56?E’D :>>F?:EJ 7@C @77:4:2= 24ED 4@F=5 5C:G6 E96 E9C66 =:36C2=DE@ 5:DD6?E( H9:=6 D@>6 4@?D6CG2E:G6D >2J 32=< 2?5 C67FD6 E@ ;@:? 2 CF=:?8 :7 :E @?=J 9@=5D E92E 2? 6I\AC6D:56?E 42? 36 AC@D64FE65)k^Am
kAmu@FC J62CD 28@( #@36CED 925 2 D@=:5 f\a >2;@C:EJ CF=6 282:?DE 2 %CF>A 4=2:> @7 “23D@=FE6 :>>F?:EJ” 2?5 @C56C E96 E96?\AC6D:56?EE@ EFC? @G6C 7:?2?4:2= 2?5 E2I C64@C5D E@ }6H *@C< AC@D64FE@CD)k^Am
kAm%96 49:67 ;FDE:46 D2:5 E96 AC6D:56?E:2= DFAC6>24J 4=2:>65 3J %CF>A 925 ?6G6C 366? A2CE @7 p>6C:42’D 9:DE@CJ)k^Am
kAm“x? @FC ;F5:4:2= DJDE6>( E96 AF3=:4 92D 2 C:89E E@ 6G6CJ >2?’D 6G:56?46) $:?46 E96 62C=:6DE 52JD @7 E96 C6AF3 =:4( ‘6G6CJ >2?’ 92D :?4=F565 E96 AC6D:56?E @7 E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D(” #@36CED HC@E6 😕 %CF>AG) ‘2?46 ) %H@ 4@?D6CG2E:G6 ;FDE:46D( p=:E@ 2?5 r=2C6?46 %9@>2D( 5:DD6?E65)k^Am
kAmrC:E:4D D2J E96 #@36CED 4@FCE 92D 2=C625J 56=:G6C65 2 G:4E@CJ @7 D@CED 7@C %CF>A 3J E2<:?8 D@ =@?8 E@ 564:56 @? 9:D :>>F?:EJ 4=2:>)k^Am
kAm“%9:D 42D6 8@6D E@ E96 962CE @7 @FC 56>@4C24J( 2?5 E96J’G6 366? D=@H\H2=<:?8 :E(” D2:5 uC65 (6CE96:>6C( AC6D:56?E @7 s6>@4C24Ja` 2?5 2 492>A:@? @7 42>A2:8? 7F?5:?8 =:>:ED D:?46 E96 (2E6C82E6 6C2) %96 4@FCE 564:565 E96 (2E6C82E6 42D6 `e 52JD 27E6C E96 @C2= 2C8F>6?E( 96 ?@E65)k^Am
kAm%9:D J62C( 3J 4@?EC2DE( E96 ;FDE:46D 92G6 E2<6? >@?E9D E@ A@?56C 2 4=2:> @7 :>>F?:EJ( 2 56=2J E92E 92D A@DEA@?65 %CF>A’D 7656C2= AC@D64FE:@?D 2?5 😀 2=>@DE 46CE2:? E@ AC6G6?E 2 ;FCJ 7C@> 564:5:?8 367@C6 E96 }@G6>36C 6=64E:@? H96E96C 96 4@?DA:C65 E@ @G6CEFC? 9:D 56762E 😕 E96 a_a_ 6=64E:@?)k^Am
kAm“%96 4@FCE D9@F=5 ?6G6C 92G6 E2<6? E9:D 42D6(” (6CE96:>6C D2:5) “%96 G@E6CD H6C6 6?E:E=65 E@ A 6?82865 😕 4C:>:?2= 4@?5F4E E@ @G6CEFC? 2? 6=64E:@? 96 =@DE)”k^Am
kAmw6’D ?@E E96 @?=J (2E6C82E6\6C2 =2HJ6C H9@ 😀 EC@F3=65) x? :7 E96 ;FDE:46D H6C6 5:G:565)k^Am
kAmyFDE `e 52JD 27E6C E96 4@FCE @C56C65 9:> E@ 5:D4=@D6 E96 E2A6D( }:I@? C6D:8?65) p >@?E9 =2E6C( !C6D:56?E u@C5 8C2?E65 9:> 2 7F== A2C5@?( 27E6C D2J:?8 9:D AC65646DD@C H2D 724:?8 “A@DD:3=6 :?5:4E>6?E 2?5 EC:2= 7@C @776?D6D 282:?DE E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D)”k^Am
kAmx? 2 C646?E :?E6CG:6H( {24@G2C2 H2C?65 282:?DE >2<:?8 2 7@C>6C AC6D:56?E :>>F?6 7C@> 4C:>:?2= AC@D64FE:@?( ?@E:?8 E92E 9:DE@CJ 92D D9@H? E92E D@>6E:>6D DEC@?8 >6? H:E9 ?@ >@C2= 4@>A2DD 42? H:? 6=64E:@?)k^Am
kAm“%92E’D H9J E9:D 4@F=5 36 E96 >@DE 52?86C@FD 564:D:@? E96 4@FCE 92D 6G6C >256(” 96 D2:5 @7 %CF>A’D 42D6) “~?46 J@F 4C24< :E @A6? 2?5 D2J E96 AC6D:56?E 86ED E@ G:@=2E6 D@>6 =2HD( E96C6’D ?@ H2J E@ 4@?DEC2:? :E) *@F 92G6 DE2CE65 5@H? 2 G6CJ 52?86C@FD C@25)”k^Am
kAmk6>mU4@AJja_ac {@D p?86=6D %:>6D) ‘:D:E 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^=2E:>6D)4@>Qm=2E:>6D)4@>k^2m) s:DEC:3FE65 3J %C:3F?6 r@?E6?E p86?4J( {{r)k^6>mk^Am
