close
close

Gaza: The war could be followed by a long Israeli campaign

Gaza: The war could be followed by a long Israeli campaign

Image description, The war has been going on since Hamas’ attack on Israel on October 7.

  • Author, Sebastian Usher
  • Role, BBC Arab Affairs Analyst
  • Report from Jerusalem

Recent comments by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that the intense phase of fighting in the Gaza Strip is nearing an end have essentially confirmed what has become increasingly clear in recent months.

The Israeli army has described its current operation in the southern city of Rafah as its last major ground offensive in the Gaza Strip.

The attack was carried out despite international opposition. Israeli attacks have killed numerous Palestinian civilians, but the bombing was not as merciless as previous attacks on Gaza and Khan Younis.

In western Rafah, Israeli forces with tank support are still fighting with Palestinian fighters, while the army continues to destroy large parts of the buildings in the city.

The Israeli military has said it has severely weakened three of the four Hamas battalions that were reportedly still in Rafah, which was Israel’s main target, raising the possibility that the army could soon declare the operation over.

None of this was any consolation for the people of Gaza. They were barely able to recover, if at all. The Hamas-controlled Ministry of Health in Gaza still puts the casualty figures at 40 to 60 deaths per day.

Israel carries out attacks elsewhere in Gaza every day – both in the north and in the center. There is currently no end in sight to these attacks. The key to Netanyahu’s strategy in Gaza is Israel’s freedom to carry out attacks when and where it deems necessary, even if all its troops are eventually withdrawn from the enclave.

In Washington, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant discussed with senior U.S. officials relatively early in the conflict what he himself called Phase C – the third, less intensive stage – of the Israeli campaign.

In one of his first meetings during his four-day visit, he told US special envoy Amos Hochstein that the transition to Phase C would “impact developments on all fronts and Israel is preparing both militarily and diplomatically for every scenario.”

He will have repeatedly emphasized this message in subsequent talks with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin.

The reference to all fronts refers primarily to the situation on Israel’s northern border, where there has been a recent escalation of fighting and rhetoric in the confrontation between Israel and the Lebanese armed movement Hezbollah, leading to speculation that a new, all-out war could be looming between Israel and another of its long-standing antagonists in the region.

Netanyahu has said that a further reduction in fighting in Gaza would free up troops that could be moved to the border with Lebanon. To underscore the increasing priority this front has become for Israel, Netanyahu was near the border and observed a military exercise.

Israeli President Isaac Herzog has also just spent two days in the region, visiting not only the military but also several communities that have been affected by Hezbollah’s almost daily attacks since October 8. Lebanese communities have also suffered from Israeli counterattacks.

day after

Whatever happens on Israel’s northern border, the conflict in Gaza, albeit at a far lower level, appears to be never ending. Efforts to reach a ceasefire have again lost momentum, and neither Israel nor Hamas seem ready to fully embrace all elements of the proposal put forward by President Biden.

There has been much talk about what will happen the day after. Israel’s war cabinet was dissolved by Netanyahu after one of its members, Benny Gantz, left it. He cited the prime minister’s failure to present a post-war plan as the main reason for his resignation.

It is still unclear whether such a plan exists. In a recent interview with a friendly Israeli media outlet, Netanyahu said it was clear that “military control will be with us for the foreseeable future.”

He then spoke perhaps most extensively about how he envisions the post-war situation in Gaza: “We also want to create a civil administration, if possible with local Palestinians and perhaps with external support from the countries of the region, which will take care of humanitarian supplies and later civil affairs in the (Gaza) Strip.”

This is in line with the goals of the Biden administration. Recent reports suggest that Egypt and the United Arab Emirates are willing to participate in a security force that could operate in Gaza after the war.

But just imagining a day after in Gaza may still be quite optimistic. Hamas and Islamic Jihad fighters can still reappear in areas from which they were previously driven out during the Israeli offensive. In essence, the war has now become a kind of guerrilla war.

The Israeli military’s chief spokesman, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, recently described the goal of destroying Hamas – making it disappear – as “simply pulling the wool over the public’s eyes.”

He said Hamas was an idea rooted in people’s hearts and that “anyone who thinks we can wipe out Hamas is wrong.”

Image description, After more than eight months of war, around 120 hostages are still being held by Hamas

This message does not seem to have reached Mr Netanyahu.

He remains adamant about his ultimate goal of a total military and political defeat of Hamas – although that goal may be reformulated in the coming weeks and months. That is why he continues to insist that Israel is free to continue its military operations if necessary, even if a ceasefire is agreed.

When he reiterated this in his interview with Channel 14, there were reports of disappointment among US officials that he was essentially negating the cornerstone of the ceasefire plan that President Biden had not only announced but also described as Israel’s own proposal.

Hamas took advantage of the opportunity to accuse Netanyahu of preventing a ceasefire agreement, although the White House has officially blamed Hamas.

In Israel, too, the families of the hostages still held in Gaza – whether alive or dead – are increasingly accusing Netanyahu of being the main obstacle to the release of their relatives.

In their latest demonstration, the hostages’ families again blocked roads across Israel. On a highway, they set fire to a metal cage emblazoned with the word “help.”

A statement said: “Netanyahu has given up hope on the hostages. They can be buried in Gaza as long as he keeps his seat.”

This third phase of Israel’s war in Gaza may be of lower intensity, but with no sign of it ending soon, the prospects of a ceasefire, the release of hostages and the start of a process by which Palestinians can rebuild their lives remain uncertain.