The song that Neil Young thought was ruined

When working on American stars and bars, However, Young was still in the golden age of what Eddie Vedder would call his “Mountain Funk” era. Although he came out with the hardest of the 1970s, Rust never sleeps, Projects like Zuma recorded what he did harvest and brought it back down to earth, almost as if you were attending a jam session rather than getting the full experience of a studio album.

It’s easy to get that same energy on this album, as Young is inspired by Crazy Horse every time he plays a tune. Although ‘Like a Hurricane’ has all the makings of a great Neil Young song and even features his signature black guitar that he used on Rust never sleepshe thought the whole thing was ruined by having him play a solo.

Young has his own vocabulary when it comes to taking a lead break, but he admitted that it was a bit too rough on “Like A Hurricane,” saying in Making a difficult peace“‘Like a Hurricane’ is probably the best example of Old Black’s tone, although if you listen closely it’s almost ruined by all the mistakes and failures in my playing. This was a memorable recording, however, because of the feeling that comes from our instrumental passages.”

On the other hand, what Young heard could hardly be described as a “failure” in any sense of the word. Are the notes always precise? Not really, but that’s not the point. A recording like this is meant to document emotion as well as instruments, and even if everything isn’t perfectly in tune, it still sounds like a band at the end of its rope, trying to do the best it can.

Admittedly, it’s also hard to tell when Young’s style stops and pure chaos begins. Take a song like “Rockin’ In the Free World,” for example. That tune is probably one of the most enduring statements a rock’n’roll artist has ever made, and yet the lead break vacillates between a weird improvised solo and the kind of freak-out a guitarist might pull after one too many drinks.

It’s nice that Young can at least look at the few mistakes that remain in his classic pieces, but this is far from a botched version. It’s just another example of an artist being human too, and since the rest of the world would tend towards more technical guitarists after this record came out, it’s refreshing to hear someone play like they’re on the verge of chaos every now and then.

Related topics