Travis Kelce performs on stage with Taylor Swift at the London Eras Tour Show

Taylor Swift had a very special guest at her last Eras Tour show: her boyfriend Travis Kelce!

At her third show at London’s Wembley Stadium on Sunday, June 23, the 34-year-old pop superstar shocked the audience by inviting the NFL star, also 34, to join her on stage.

The Kansas City Chiefs quarterback was dressed to the nines in a tuxedo and top hat and accompanied Swift during her outfit change for “I Can Do It With a Broken Heart” – a change that the singer introduced when she first The “Tortured Poets” section Album into the tour.

Not only did Kelce share the stage with Swift—a first for the musician and singer—but he also gave it his all, replacing the dancer who usually carries the Grammy winner onto the stage during this segment.

The tight end needed no introduction and was all smiles as he carried Swift and gently set her down on a red couch in the middle of the stage.

Just like Kelce, the crowd of fans could hardly contain their enthusiasm and roared loudly as the football professional effortlessly lifted the singer across the stage at Wembley Stadium and onto the couch.

The NFL star also joined in on the rest of the segment by faking Swift’s makeup during the outfit change and dusting her face with powder.

He also performed some of his signature dance moves and smiled broadly before leaving the stage.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Kelce’s appearance came just days after he and Swift went Instagram official on Friday, June 21, with a selfie taken backstage at the star’s first London show with Prince William, Prince George and Princess Charlotte.

It was also Kelce’s first time on stage with Swift, but the athlete has been a fixture in the Eras Tour crowd since the two began dating last year – just as she was during his NFL season.

The first rumors of a relationship between the two emerged in September 2023 after Swift attended some of Kelce’s games.

In February 2024, Kelce further explained the timeline of their romance, revealing that the couple had been dating for about a month before Swift attended her first game – calling the time they spent together “a crazy, crazy journey.”